Colin Cowherd Criticizes Andy Reid's Legacy Without Mahomes | NFL Wires
.png)
Sports commentator Colin Cowherd stirs controversy by claiming Andy Reid's success is all thanks to Patrick Mahomes. NFL Wires investigates the claims, reactions, and what this means for the Chiefs.
Cowherd Sparks Firestorm with Bold Claim
In a recent episode of The Herd, sports analyst Colin Cowherd dropped a bombshell statement that has rippled across the NFL community: “Andy Reid’s entire legacy is propped up by Patrick Mahomes. Without him, Reid is just another good coach with a long resume and no rings.”
The comment, aimed directly at the Kansas City Chiefs' head coach, was met with immediate pushback from fans and pundits alike. Still, Cowherd doubled down, citing Reid’s playoff shortcomings prior to Mahomes’ arrival.
Breaking Down the Numbers
Cowherd’s argument hinges on one central fact: Reid had zero Super Bowl titles before Mahomes took over as starter in 2018. Though Reid led the Philadelphia Eagles to multiple NFC Championship games and one Super Bowl appearance, he never clinched the big one.
Since teaming up with Mahomes, however, Reid has claimed three AFC Championships and two Super Bowl wins, elevating him into the conversation of the all-time greats.
Analyst Opinions: Is It Fair?
Some analysts agree with Cowherd’s perspective but add nuance. NFL Wires contributor Dana Kelton said, “There’s no denying Mahomes helped Reid reach new heights, but it’s equally true that Reid developed Mahomes into the QB he is today.”
Others call Cowherd’s take disrespectful, noting Reid’s offensive innovations and ability to adapt across multiple decades. “He’s a Hall of Fame coach regardless,” said former QB Kurt Warner.
What This Means for Andy Reid’s Legacy
If Reid were to win another Super Bowl without Mahomes in the future, it could put these debates to rest. But for now, the question lingers: how much of his success is coaching genius, and how much is Mahomes magic?
Reid himself has never shied away from giving Mahomes credit. “You want guys like him as your leader,” Reid said during last year’s playoffs. “But it takes a team — and we coach that way.”
Fanbase Reaction: Divided
Kansas City fans were quick to jump to Reid’s defense on social media. Tweets flooded in defending his full body of work, pointing to his coaching tree, development of multiple Pro Bowl QBs, and consistent playoff appearances.
Meanwhile, a smaller contingent of fans expressed cautious agreement. “Let’s be honest — without 15 [Mahomes], we’re probably not celebrating rings,” one user wrote.
Looking Forward
As long as Reid and Mahomes continue their partnership, this debate will remain largely theoretical. But Cowherd’s comments have stirred the pot just enough to reignite discussions about coaching legacy versus quarterback talent.
NFL Wires will be tracking this story as it evolves — and as the Chiefs head into another season with Super Bowl aspirations.
Tyreek Hill Biography:
Career, Stats, Net Worth & Life Story
