Patrick Mahomes Drops in Recent QB Ranking Based on 2024 Performance | NFL Wires

Patrick Mahomes Drops in Recent QB Ranking Based on 2024 Performance | NFL Wires

Despite being ranked among the NFL’s elite, Patrick Mahomes fell below top QBs like Joe Burrow and Josh Allen in a recent ranking focused on last season’s metrics. Get the full breakdown on NFL Wires.

ntroduction: Mahomes’ Elite Status Questioned

Patrick Mahomes has been the NFL’s defining quarterback for years, but recent performance-based rankings focused solely on 2024 have seen him slip. Analysts, notably Chris Simms, now place him behind three quarterbacks—Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow—based on metrics and execution last season.

This shift raises questions: Was 2024 an anomaly, or is the NFL landscape evolving?

Chris Simms Drops Mahomes to 4th

On the Unbuttoned podcast and NBC Sports, Chris Simms stated that while Mahomes remains clutch and clutch-worthy, his week-in, week-out performance in 2024 didn’t match Jackson, Allen, or Burrow.

Simms noted:

“One of the greatest ... but based on 2024 alone, others played better.”

 

Simms highlighted statistical dips, including Mahomes’ playoff QBR ranking (8th in 2024), as key metrics behind the decision .

PFF Says Mahomes Remains No. 1—Though Margin Is Slim

Pro Football Focus (PFF) continues to rank Mahomes at the top of its 2025 QB list, based on his 86.0 passing grade over the past two seasons.

However, PFF acknowledges that his dominance is no longer uncontested:

• Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, and Josh Allen are within sight in terms of performance grades.

• 
  

Despite solid overall placement, PFF describes his lead as "the slimmest margin ever" .

What the Rankings Really Mean

• Short-Term Regression? Yes—some metrics show decline.

• Enduring Elite? Equally clear—context, clutch play, and pedigree remain strong.

• Key Factors:

  • 2024 QBR drop

  • Slight reduction in passing efficiency

  • Defensive shifts and personnel changes in KC

NFL Wires’ Take: Rankings Are Context-Driven

Metrics and rankings offer snapshots—but May not predict future success.

• Simms’ ranking emphasizes pure 2024 performance.

• PFF values consistency and career trajectory.

• Reality check: Even a “down” Mahomes leads his team to the AFC Championship Game and remains a three-time Super Bowl winner.

Bottom line: He may be unfavored in stats-mode, but Mahomes remains the NFL’s benchmark QB.

Conclusion: The Chase Is On, But Mahomes Is Still the Pace Car

Yes, Mahomes dropped to fourth in Simms’ 2024-centric ranking. Yes, his statistical edge narrowed. But elite QBs like Burrow, Jackson, and Allen are closing the gap—not overtaking him. Mahomes is still Kansas City’s engine, clutch performer, and benchmark quarterback.

Expect 2025 to be a defining year—but don’t expect Mahomes to fall off top-tier radar anytime soon.

Tyreek Hill Biography: Career, Stats, Net Worth & Life Story